butter_on_toast
Brand
Price

Top filters (6)

Variety
Expert taste test score
Nutrition score
Price per 100g
Shop Ethical rating

Nutrition (4)

Energy per 100g (kJ)
Sodium per 100g (mg)
Saturated fat per 100g (g)
Percentage of milk fat

Sustainability (3)

Country of origin

Sort by

Filter by

Best butter

Last updated: 11 November 2022
Fact-checked
Fact-checked
Checked for accuracy by our qualified fact-checkers and verifiers. Find out more about fact-checking at CHOICE
User 1000000003043 User 1000000003043

We taste tested and reviewed 44 supermarket butters, from brands including Allowrie, Devondale, Lurpak, Mainland, Pepe Saya and Western Star, to see which is the cream of the crop. 

  • Discover the top-rated butter by CHOICE experts.
  • Sort by price, brand, type and more.
  • Check out the butter buying guide for tips on how to buy, use and store butter.

We’ve partnered with Shop Ethical on this review to show the ratings that the Ethical Consumer Group gives to each company (not product).

Products list

Table icon View full comparison table
Displaying all 39 products
CHOICE Expert Rating (High-Low)
Price (Low-High)
Brand (A-Z)
CHOICE Expert Rating (High-Low)
Recommended
Price per 100g (Low-High)
Energy per 100g (kJ) (Low-High)
Sodium per 100g (mg) (Low-High)
Saturated fat per 100g (g) (Low-High)
Health Star Rating (High-Low)
Shop Ethical rating (Best-Worst)
Sorry, no products meet the criteria for the filters you've applied.
Image of Kerrygold Pure Irish Salted Butter
79
Recommended

Kerrygold Pure Irish Salted Butter

Pure Irish Salted Butter

Expert taste test score 87%
Price per 100g $2.6
Health Star Rating 0.5
Country of origin Ireland
$6.5
Join CHOICE
Image of Lurpak Butter Slightly Salted
76
Recommended

Lurpak Butter Slightly Salted

Butter Slightly Salted

Expert taste test score 84%
Price per 100g $2.32
Health Star Rating 0.5
Country of origin Denmark
$5.8
Join CHOICE
Image of Meander Valley Salted Butter Cultured
76
Recommended

Meander Valley Salted Butter Cultured

Salted Butter Cultured

Expert taste test score 83%
Price per 100g $3.08
Health Star Rating 0.5
Country of origin Australia
$7.7
Join CHOICE
Image of Westgold Unsalted New Zealand Grass-Fed Butter
75
Recommended

Westgold Unsalted New Zealand Grass-Fed Butter

Unsalted New Zealand Grass-Fed Butter

Expert taste test score 81%
Price per 100g $1.25
Health Star Rating 1
Country of origin New Zealand
$5
Join CHOICE
Image of Ballantyne Traditional Salted Butter
74

Ballantyne Traditional Salted Butter

Traditional Salted Butter

Expert taste test score 81%
Price per 100g $3.4
Health Star Rating 0.5
Country of origin Australia
$6.79
Join CHOICE
Image of Coles Australian Butter Salted
74

Coles Australian Butter Salted

Australian Butter Salted

Expert taste test score 81%
Price per 100g $1.72
Health Star Rating 0.5
Country of origin Australia
$4.3
Join CHOICE
Image of Allowrie Unsalted Butter Choicest Grade
73

Allowrie Unsalted Butter Choicest Grade

Unsalted Butter Choicest Grade

Expert taste test score 79%
Price per 100g $2.08
Health Star Rating 1
Country of origin Australia
$5.2
Join CHOICE
Image of Devondale Unsalted Butter
73

Devondale Unsalted Butter

Unsalted Butter

Expert taste test score 79%
Price per 100g $2.12
Health Star Rating 1
Country of origin Australia
$5.3
Join CHOICE
Image of Kerrygold Pure Irish Butter Unsalted
73

Kerrygold Pure Irish Butter Unsalted

Pure Irish Butter Unsalted

Expert taste test score 79%
Price per 100g $2.6
Health Star Rating 1
Country of origin Ireland
$6.5
Join CHOICE
Image of Lurpak Butter Unsalted
73

Lurpak Butter Unsalted

Butter Unsalted

Expert taste test score 79%
Price per 100g $2.32
Health Star Rating 1
Country of origin Denmark
$5.8
Join CHOICE
Image of Macro Certified Organic Butter Salted
73

Macro Certified Organic Butter Salted

Certified Organic Butter Salted

Expert taste test score 80%
Price per 100g $1.94
Health Star Rating 0.5
Country of origin Australia
$4.85
Join CHOICE
Image of Mainland Certified Organic Butter Salted
73

Mainland Certified Organic Butter Salted

Certified Organic Butter Salted

Expert taste test score 80%
Price per 100g $2.4
Health Star Rating 0.5
Country of origin New Zealand
$6
Join CHOICE
Image of Great Ocean Road Butter with Sea Salt
72

Great Ocean Road Butter with Sea Salt

Butter with Sea Salt

Expert taste test score 79%
Price per 100g $2.08
Health Star Rating 0.5
Country of origin Australia
$5.2
Join CHOICE
Image of The Organic Milk Co Organic Salted Butter
72

The Organic Milk Co Organic Salted Butter

Organic Salted Butter

Expert taste test score 79%
Price per 100g $2.32
Health Star Rating 0.5
Country of origin Australia
$5.8
Join CHOICE
Image of True Organic Australian Organic Unsalted Butter
72

True Organic Australian Organic Unsalted Butter

Australian Organic Unsalted Butter

Expert taste test score 78%
Price per 100g $2.8
Health Star Rating 1
Country of origin Australia
$6.99
Join CHOICE
Image of Western Star Original Salted Butter
72

Western Star Original Salted Butter

Original Salted Butter

Expert taste test score 79%
Price per 100g $2.08
Health Star Rating 0.5
Country of origin Australia
$5.2
Join CHOICE
Image of Aldi Beautifully Butterfully Salted Butter
71

Aldi Beautifully Butterfully Salted Butter

Beautifully Butterfully Salted Butter

Expert taste test score 78%
Price per 100g $1.38
Health Star Rating 0.5
Country of origin Australia
$3.45
Join CHOICE
Image of Macro Certified Organic Unsalted Butter
71

Macro Certified Organic Unsalted Butter

Certified Organic Unsalted Butter

Expert taste test score 77%
Price per 100g $1.94
Health Star Rating 1
Country of origin Australia
$4.85
Join CHOICE
Image of The Organic Milk Co Organic Butter Unsalted
70

The Organic Milk Co Organic Butter Unsalted

Organic Butter Unsalted

Expert taste test score 75%
Price per 100g $2.32
Health Star Rating 1
Country of origin Australia
$5.8
Join CHOICE
Image of Westgold Salted New Zealand Grass-Fed Butter
70

Westgold Salted New Zealand Grass-Fed Butter

Salted New Zealand Grass-Fed Butter

Expert taste test score 77%
Price per 100g $1.25
Health Star Rating 0.5
Country of origin New Zealand
$5
Join CHOICE
Image of Great Ocean Road Butter Unsalted
69

Great Ocean Road Butter Unsalted

Butter Unsalted

Expert taste test score 74%
Price per 100g $2.08
Health Star Rating 1
Country of origin Australia
$5.2
Join CHOICE
Image of President French Made Salted Butter
69

President French Made Salted Butter

French Made Salted Butter

Expert taste test score 75%
Price per 100g $2.5
Health Star Rating 0.5
Country of origin France
$5
Join CHOICE
Image of Coles Certified Organic Unsalted Butter
68

Coles Certified Organic Unsalted Butter

Certified Organic Unsalted Butter

Expert taste test score 73%
Price per 100g $1.94
Health Star Rating 1
Country of origin Australia
$4.85
Join CHOICE
Image of Aldi Beautifully Butterfully Unsalted
67

Aldi Beautifully Butterfully Unsalted

Beautifully Butterfully Unsalted

Expert taste test score 73%
Price per 100g $1.38
Health Star Rating 1
Country of origin Australia
$3.45
Join CHOICE
Image of Harris Farm Butter Salted
67

Harris Farm Butter Salted

Butter Salted

Expert taste test score 74%
Price per 100g $1.72
Health Star Rating 0.5
Country of origin Australia
$4.29
Join CHOICE
Image of Absolute Organic Unsalted Butter
66

Absolute Organic Unsalted Butter

Unsalted Butter

Expert taste test score 71%
Price per 100g $3.56
Health Star Rating 1
Country of origin Belgium
$8.89
Join CHOICE
Image of Coles Certified Organic Butter Salted
66

Coles Certified Organic Butter Salted

Certified Organic Butter Salted

Expert taste test score 73%
Price per 100g $1.94
Health Star Rating 0.5
Country of origin Australia
$4.85
Join CHOICE
Image of Devondale Salted Butter
65

Devondale Salted Butter

Salted Butter

Expert taste test score 71%
Price per 100g $2.12
Health Star Rating 0.5
Country of origin Australia
$5.3
Join CHOICE
Image of Woolworths Australian Salted Butter
65

Woolworths Australian Salted Butter

Australian Salted Butter

Expert taste test score 71%
Price per 100g $1.72
Health Star Rating 0.5
Country of origin Australia
$4.3
Join CHOICE
Image of Western Star Unsalted Butter
64

Western Star Unsalted Butter

Unsalted Butter

Expert taste test score 69%
Price per 100g $2.08
Health Star Rating 1
Country of origin Australia
$5.2
Join CHOICE
Image of Absolute Organic Salted Butter
63

Absolute Organic Salted Butter

Salted Butter

Expert taste test score 69%
Price per 100g $3.56
Health Star Rating 0.5
Country of origin Belgium
$8.89
Join CHOICE
Image of Coles Australian Butter Unsalted
63

Coles Australian Butter Unsalted

Australian Butter Unsalted

Expert taste test score 68%
Price per 100g $1.72
Health Star Rating 1
Country of origin Australia
$4.3
Join CHOICE
Image of Pure Valley Organic Australian Butter Salted
63

Pure Valley Organic Australian Butter Salted

Organic Australian Butter Salted

Expert taste test score 69%
Price per 100g $1.8
Health Star Rating 0.5
Country of origin Australia
$4.49
Join CHOICE
Image of True Organic Australian Organic Salted Butter
63

True Organic Australian Organic Salted Butter

Australian Organic Salted Butter

Expert taste test score 69%
Price per 100g $2.8
Health Star Rating 0.5
Country of origin Australia
$6.99
Join CHOICE
Image of Allowrie Choicest Butter Salted
62

Allowrie Choicest Butter Salted

Choicest Butter Salted

Expert taste test score 68%
Price per 100g $2.08
Health Star Rating 0.5
Country of origin Australia
$5.2
Join CHOICE
Image of Woolworths Australian Butter Unsalted
61

Woolworths Australian Butter Unsalted

Australian Butter Unsalted

Expert taste test score 65%
Price per 100g $1.72
Health Star Rating 1
Country of origin Australia
$4.3
Join CHOICE
Image of Lard Ass Cultured Butter Salted
60

Lard Ass Cultured Butter Salted

Cultured Butter Salted

Expert taste test score 66%
Price per 100g $5.33
Health Star Rating 0.5
Country of origin Australia
$12
Join CHOICE
Image of Pepe Saya Australian Cultured Salted Butter
59

Pepe Saya Australian Cultured Salted Butter

Australian Cultured Salted Butter

Expert taste test score 64%
Price per 100g $4
Health Star Rating 0.5
Country of origin Australia
$9
Join CHOICE
Image of President French Made Unsalted Butter
59

President French Made Unsalted Butter

French Made Unsalted Butter

Expert taste test score 64%
Price per 100g $2.5
Health Star Rating 1
Country of origin France
$5
Join CHOICE
Shadia Djakovic
User 1000000003043

Shadia worked at CHOICE until 2024.She is an accredited practising dietitian and nutritionist and has been a member of the Dietitians Association of Australia since 2012. She has a degree in food science and nutrition and a master's degree in nutrition and dietetics, and she's also studied business. Before working at CHOICE, Shadia worked as a nutritionist within the food industry, a clinical dietitian, worked in health promotion, and did some lecturing at a university. As a content producer at CHOICE, she was responsible for testing a range of food categories looking at taste and nutrition. Shadia is passionate about food and nutrition and the role sustainability plays in these areas, and she loves cooking and developing recipes. You can follow her on LinkedIn.

Shadia worked at CHOICE until 2024.She is an accredited practising dietitian and nutritionist and has been a member of the Dietitians Association of Australia since 2012. She has a degree in food science and nutrition and a master's degree in nutrition and dietetics, and she's also studied business. Before working at CHOICE, Shadia worked as a nutritionist within the food industry, a clinical dietitian, worked in health promotion, and did some lecturing at a university. As a content producer at CHOICE, she was responsible for testing a range of food categories looking at taste and nutrition. Shadia is passionate about food and nutrition and the role sustainability plays in these areas, and she loves cooking and developing recipes. You can follow her on LinkedIn.